Vietnam Business Channel

Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) – 10 years’ reflection and real estate development

New Page 1

Image courtesy of JLL AP

Over the past 10 years, despite the ups and downs of Vietnam's economy in general and the real estate market in particular, FDI inflows remained stable with the cumulative total registered FDI reached the level of approximately US$318.72 billion by the end of 2017, in which cumulative direct investment in the real estate sector achieved US$53.2 billion, according to FIA's statistics.

Most notably, FDI into Vietnam in the recent 3 years (2015-17) has continuously increased as compared to the period of 2010-13 and most of the capital inflow was deployed into projects. In contrast, capital inflows to Vietnam in 2007 was triple that of 2005, and peaked in 2008 with the registered amount of almost US$72billion, as capital inflows almost quadrupled in a year (Figure 1). It is important to note that most of the capital was not deployed into projects during that time. While capital inflow in 2008 was six times higher than 2005, the number of projects implemented was just 10% higher in 2008 compared to 2005. However, this amount was never fully disbursed. The FDI in the recent years is to attract realistic projects that will disburse their commitment rather than holding while attracting co-investors.

Figure 1: FDI's by year (US$ million)

25
Source: GSO, FIA

[1] Cumulative registered FDI is the successive additions of registered investment from effective projects only up until 20th December 2017.

FDI inflow into Vietnam real estate market

Over the years, FDI inflows into the real estate sector in Vietnam have often been ranked second or third, followed by manufacturing – the largest recipient of FDI among Vietnam's sectors. (Figure 2).

Figure 2: Top 5 Vietnam's FDI by economic activity

26
Source: FIA Vietnam / Cumulative to 20/12/2017 - Effective projects only

Vietnam's strong and stable growth performance over the past decade has been an attractive magnet for foreign investors, especially those from Asia such as Japan, Korea, Singapore, Hong Kong, Taiwan and China. Their market share accounted for 73.9% of total FDI of all industries including real estate, followed by the EU countries at 15.2% (Figure 3). Most of EU investors invest in the fields such as design, electronics, home appliances and furniture, etc. However, with the need to expand their footprint to Vietnam, these European firms also have increasing demand for direct investment in commercial real estate through acquiring buildings for their headquarters or showrooms in non-CBD areas.

American investors are also key players in Vietnamese market as they ranked third in FDI capital. Although there are no official breakdown statistics on FDI inflows into real estate sector by countries, it can be seen that there has been increasing interest from private equity firms in real estate market as they consider Vietnam to be an attractive investment destination. One of the notable American investors is the New York-based private equity firm Warburg Pincus, who has committed over US$1 billion in Vietnam, in which a majority of this fund is allocated to set up real estate platforms including retail, hotels, industrial and logistics.

Figure 3: Breakdown of Vietnam's FDI by region (*)

27
Source: FIA Vietnam / * Foreign direct invested capital till valid as of 20 Dec.2017

FDI of all economic activities including real estates. FDI from the EU is ranked second following Asia.

High-end residential market – the top choice of foreign investors

As more than 10 years ago, FDI inflows were concentrated in the high-end residential segment. Famous names in the market such as Keppel Land, CapitaLand with the first high-end real estate projects in Vietnam such as The Estella or The Vista. With the total supply of high-end apartments in HCMC as of 4Q2007 at approximately 1,700 units, of which about 1,000 units were from FDI projects, it is clear that this is a very small proportion compared to the total population of 6.85 million people in the same year.

Since the market share of FDI projects is not high, the average price of high-end primary stocks in 2007 was at US$2,800/sqm (exchange rate 16,112 VND/US$), representing an increase of 86% as compared to the sales launch of the previous year. This created a virtual supply-demand imbalance that pushed prices beyond affordability of homebuyers with real demand. There has been a long queue of buyers trying to compete for a very limited availability of these products due to virtual speculation. During this period, the expected return of real estate investment projects by foreign investors is usually at 30% - 35%, which is very high and attractive for real estate projects, leading to the status of registered FDI on real estate investment, mainly from the Asian countries, reached a record high in 2008, up to US$23 billion, accounting for more than 30% FDI registered capital. (In the last three years, this rate is maintained at 7% -9%).


Until March 2008, with the overheating of the market in 2007 and the impact of the global financial crisis, monetary instruments were unmanageable as interest rates increased rapidly, which reached 25% and peak inflation at 23%. Subsequently, the real estate market fell into a recession and FDI inflows to real estate sector also decreased. This capital flow started to recover by the end of 2013, early 2014.

Since then, the market has become more familiar with the names of other FDI investors such as Hong Kong Land (The Nassim project), Frasers Property (Q2 Thao Dien project) or Mapletree (One Verandah project). JLL also noted that they are not new investors in the Vietnamese market, but rather looking to expand their residential portfolio outside of traditional investment in the construction / ownership of leading Grade A or Grade B office buildings in Hanoi (Pacific Place, Central Building, 63 Ly Thai To) or in HCMC such as M Plaza and Me Linh Point Tower. In addition, there are other prestigious investors from Japan such as Daiwa House, Nomura and Sumitomo to invest in projects in District 7 or Korean corporations such as Lotte Group, GS Investments in Thu Thiem New Urban Area in District 2.

Emerging trend to expand FDI inflows into the mid-end and affordable housing segments

With the recovery of the real estate market, foreign investors, especially those from Japan, are looking to pour their capital into Vietnamese real estate market. This is proven by the deals announced in the past three years by Japanese investors such as Hankyu Realty and Nishi Nippon Railroad in cooperation with Nam Long or Sanyo Homes and Tien Phat, and most recently the joint venture between Mitsubishi Corporation and Phuc Khang. Investment segment of diversified joint ventures are targeting the mid-end and affordable segment. Following this trend, there are many investors considering and willing to participate in joint ventures and contribute capital with reputable Vietnamese investors. The advantages of such joint ventures are that the Vietnamese local investors can contribute their understanding and knowledge of the market, the legal system, the established list of real estate portfolio while foreign investors with strong financial capacity and real estate project development expertise will add more value to the project.

And commercial real estate with FDI also gradually increases supply over the years

With the total office supply 10 years ago was about 650,000 m2, until now, this number has increased by three times, of which, the supply from office buildings with FDI contributions increased to 500,000 m2, doubled since the past 10 years. Previously, with the demand for Grade A office space, tenants have only a handful of options from Grade A buildings built since the 90s, such as Sunwah Tower, Diamond Plaza, Saigon Center (Phase 1) or Metropolitan. Over the past five years, the market has witnessed a significant increase in Grade A supply from FDI investors such as Vietcombank Tower, Saigon Center (Phase 2) and Deutsches Haus. Not only the traditional office business, the office market embraces a diversity of new investment concepts such as co-working spaces or serviced offices. We expect the trend to accelerate, due to (1) changing demographics and working styles; (2) companies realizing the need for flexibility in their leases due to rapid changes in business environment.

Real estate FDI prospects for 2018

2018 marks a 10-year period since the downturn of the real estate market and nearly 5 years of market recovery. Given the monetary policies are expected to stay neutral-to-accommodative to support growth when FDI inflows in hundred millions of dollars are poised to enter the real estate market in Vietnam, we expect the real estate market to continue stabilizing and growing. M&A activities and other forms of direct investment will continue to reach new records.

We forecast the real estate market outlook as following:

- Deals are available but harder to execute due to divergence in pricing expectations between buyers and sellers.

- More opportunistic funds will focus on new areas (e.g. school, hospital, construction).

- Limited yield compression but asset prices should rise further due to rent growth.

- Demand for co-working space is growing from both small and large enterprises.

- REITs to expand capital sources. By the end of 2017, the notable transactions of Pullman Jakarta Central Park Hotel in Indonesia, Capri by Frasers HCMC and IBIS HCMC in Ho Chi Minh City with total investment portfolio value of US$130 million by a Thai-listed REIT (SHREIT) have proven the intra-regional capital flows and the appeal of investment assets in Vietnam to international investors.

- Continued strong interest in industrial and logistics assets. The lack of high specification, modern logistics warehouse space and strong demand from regional occupiers are supporting for the potential growth of this industry. As such, this sector remains on the radar of foreign investors and developers in 2018.

Overview on M&A activities in Vietnam 1H 2018

By Khanh Nguyen, Associate Director, Capital Markets, Vietnam, JLL

Vietnam, 5 July 2018 – Vietnam has become an attractive destination for many foreign investors largely due to the country's friendly policies encouraging FDI, its political stability and strong economy. Foreign direct investment (FDI) disbursements rose 8.4% year-on-year to US$8.37 billion in the first six months of 2018, according to Foreign Investment Agency statistics. Furthermore, Vietnam has been taking initiatives to improve its transparency to the next level, according to JLL's Global Real Estate Transparency Index. Vietnam remains one of the most favorable destinations for foreign investment in South East Asia.

Within the first half of 2018, the Vietnamese real estate market continues to show irresistible appeal to foreign investors and continued to witness high-value merger and acquisition (M&A) transactions in a variety of sectors such as residential, commercial and industrial. Joint ventures have become popular among foreign developers who have strong financial capacity and track record joining forces with local developers who own land and have strong connection with the local community. Foreign investors are from many different countries such as Japan, Korea, Singapore, with an increasing number of groups from mainland China. JLL observes that there is an increasing number of local investors who are actively seeking for real estate deals alongside with foreign investors.

2018 starts off with the acquisition of Sun Wah office tower by Nomura Real Estate Development. According to their press release in January this year, Nomura acquired 24% stake in the Grade A office building located in prime location of District 1, Ho Chi Minh City. This was the company's first office project in Vietnam and second project in the country, after their investment in a condominium project "Phu My Hung Midtown" in District 7, Ho Chi Minh City. This transaction has shown Nomura's strong interest in the Vietnamese market and their long-term commitment in the country.

The residential sector continued to be buoyant with five major M&A transactions within the first six months. In March, CapitaLand announced that its wholly owned subsidiary CVH Nereus Pte. Ltd. acquired 16.9 million ordinary shares, representing 99.5% of the charter capital of Hien Duc Tay Ho Joint Stock Company ("HDTH"), for a total cash consideration of approximately VND 685 billion (approximately US$29.8 million), subject to usual post-completion adjustments. HDTH owns a 0.9-ha development land plot in Tay Ho District, Hanoi which will be developed into a mixed-use development consisting of residential and Small Office Home Office (SoHo) apartments, office and retail space.

According to their announcement in April, Frasers Property entered into a conditional share purchase agreement with Tran Thai Lands Company Limited to acquire 24 million ordinary shares, representing 75% of the issued share capital of Phu An Khang Real Estate Joint Stock Company ("PAK"). It is intended that PAK will undertake the development of a residential and commercial project on a mixed-use development land plot in District 2, Ho Chi Minh City that is held by PAK. The aggregate consideration for the proposed acquisition is VND 408.6 billion (equivalent to approximately US$18 million).

Another major mixed-use residential development deal in June 2018 is the divestment of Keppel Land's stakes in Quoc Loc Phat JSC ("QLP")'s development project in District 2, Ho Chi Minh City. Keppel Corporation Limited has recently announced in their press release that its wholly-owned subsidiary, Keppel Land Limited ("KLL"), through KLL's wholly-owned subsidiaries Keppel Land Thu Thiem Pte. Ltd. and its indirect wholly owned subsidiary, Orbista Pte. Ltd. (which owned 20% and 25% shareholding interest in QLP respectively) has entered into a sales and purchase agreement to divest their stake in QLP for VND702.0 billion (equivalent to approximately US$30.6 million). Following the transaction, KLL will hold 15% interest in QLP through Orbista. After the completion of the aforementioned transaction, Keppel Corporation Limited intends to divest its remaining indirect interest of 15% shareholding in QLP, which is held through its wholly owned subsidiary, Oil Asia Pte. Ltd., which in turns, holds 100% of the shareholding interest in Orbista. Further announcements will be made by Keppel Corporation Limited regarding to this subsequent divestment.

Within the same month, Malaysia's Berjaya Land Berhad announced that its wholly-owned subsidiary, Berjaya Leisure (Cayman) Limited ("BLeisure Cayman"), had divested its entire resultant 32.5% of the capital contribution in Berjaya Vietnam Financial Center Limited ("BVFC") to Vinhomes Joint Stock Company ("Vinhomes") and Can Gio Tourist City Corporation for a cash consideration of VND884.9 billion (approximately US$38.4 million). Prior to the disposal of BVFC, BLeisure Cayman's capital contribution of VND967.3 billion (equivalent to US$42 million) represented 100% of the charter capital of BVFC. However, Vinhomes had in March 2018 injected fresh capital contribution of VND2,008.7 billion (equivalent to approximately US$87.3 million) following the conditions imposed by the Vietnamese authorities, resulting in a dilution of BLeisure Caymans' holding in the charter capital of BVFC from 100% to 32.5%. According to their press release, BVFC is developing the project comprising "office building, a five-star hotel, service residences and shopping mall on a 6.64-ha land located in District 10, Ho Chi Minh City". The company has not yet to commence operations.

In addition, according to the same announcement from Berjaya Land Berhad in 4th June 2018, Vingroup and its affiliates will potentially acquire Berjaya Vietnam International University Town One Member Limited Liability Company ("BVIUT") and have in December 2017 injected a cash sum of VND 11,904 billion (equivalent to approximately US$518 million) as capital contribution into BVIUT. Effectively, the consortium has raised its stake in the firm to 99.2%. BLeisure Cayman's initial stake in BVIUT has been diluted from 100% to 0.8% and the company intends to dispose the remaining stake in the near future.

Investment deals in 1H 2018 were diversified with a good variety of asset and property types transacted. In May 2018, Sembcorp Industries (Sembcorp) announced in their press release that Sembcorp Infra Services (SIS), a subsidiary of Sembcorp's wholly-owned entity Sembcorp Development, entered into a share subscription agreement with CRE Asia in respect of the proposed subscription to new shares to be issued by SIS. SIS will see its share capital increased to 20.5 million ordinary shares via the issuance of new ordinary shares, and CRE Asia has agreed to invest US$6.2 million into SIS in exchange for 6.2 million new ordinary shares, or 30% of the enlarged capital, with Sembcorp Development holding the remaining 70%.

SIS and its wholly-owned subsidiary SIS Hai Phong are the developers of around 30,000 sqm of warehouse space within the Vietnam Singapore Industrial Park integrated township (VSIP) in Hai Phong, Vietnam. The new capital from CRE Asia and bank borrowings will fund the development of an additional 30,000 sqm of warehouse space in Vietnam by SIS.

When looking at the market as a whole we expect continued growth through most asset types. Hospitality has been interesting over the past year with new funds with foreign capital now specifically targeting this sector. We expect that this trend will continue in hospitality, and in other growing sectors such as industrial and alternatives like education. The affordable housing market is another key growing sector, now drawing specialist capital sources who identify value in these underlying fundamentals including growing middle class.

We expect foreign investors to continue showing their keen interest and strong commitment in Vietnamese real estate market, and that the market in still growing. Both incumbent and incoming foreign investors are actively hunting for "clean" and "clear" projects that can meet their required returns and conditions. Due to the strong focus on Vietnam from regional investors, we expect M&A activities to reach new record levels in 2018.

List of some M&A transactions in Vietnam 1H18:


Source: Real Capital Analytics

Date

Property Name

Type

City

Jun-18

The Vietnam Financial Centre

Dev Site

Ho Chi Minh City

May-18

Binh Xuyen II industrial park land plot

Dev Site

Binh Xuyen

Apr-18

District 2 land plot

Dev Site

Ho Chi Minh City

Apr-18

Vietnam International University (VIUT) Project

Dev Site

Ho Chi Minh City

Apr-18

Ngan Binh Complex

Dev Site

Ho Chi Minh City

Apr-18

Eco-Green Saigon

Dev Site

Ho Chi Minh City

Mar-18

Malibu project

Dev Site

Hoi An

Feb-18

Tay Ho District land plot

Dev Site

Ha Noi

Jan-18

51 Phan Boi Chau

Dev Site

Ha Noi

Jan-18

Sunwah Tower

Office

Ho Chi Minh City

Jan-18

Project Site Guest Park Hyatt Hanoi

Dev Site

Ha Noi

 



Note:
This article was written by Khanh Nguyen, Associate Director, Capital Markets, JLL Vietnam, and is provided courtesy of JLL Vietnam, which own all copyrights. For more information on JLL Asia visit them at: https://www.joneslanglasalle.com.vn